• About
  • Contact
  • Closets

Countdown to Friday

A Secondhand Style and Travel File

  • Fashion
  • Reselling
  • Travel
  • Lifestyle
    • Beauty
    • Fitness
    • Home
    • Gift Guides

The Ups and Downs of Starting a Poshmark Closet

May 15, 2019

Poshmark Closet

Attention everyone! If you haven’t heard about me thrifting enough, I’m about to take it to another level…my Poshmark closet full of gently used, name brand clothes is live! You can easily check out what I have listed via the widget in the sidebar or see my Poshmark closet here.

If you haven’t heard of Poshmark, it’s a reselling platform with much more of a social media vibe. It’s mostly known for the reselling of clothes, and is THE place to get gently used name brand items. I’ve always been interested in Poshmark, but never actually bought or listed anything. As I became more involved in thrifting and found so many great items that weren’t necessarily something I wanted but knew others might, I started to do some more research.

It turns out there are people who resell on Poshmark as a full time job. Yes, you read that right, a full time job! There are also people who just like to resell their own items, and others who simply resell part time. It’s a really fascinating community!

Side Note: As I took a pause here in writing this post to check Poshmark, I found out I sold my first item! Hooray! Thank you to the lovely lady in Seattle for buying the striped Madewell sweater I listed 🙂

As I started to learn more about Poshmark, particularly becoming a part time seller, I had a lot of different feelings. First of all, how exciting to think about the possibility of extra income from something I’m already doing (thrifting)! But also, how scary…what if I don’t sell anything? What if it’s a lot of work and not as much reward as I’m hoping?

In today’s post I’m going to talk about some of the ups and downs with getting my Poshmark closet started.

Starting My Poshmark Inventory

Shopping Cart of Thrift Store Finds

It was Saturday, approximately 11am, and I was in the thrift store with a shopping cart overflowing with items I wanted to have as my Poshmark inventory. I spent forever going through the thrift store and checking comparable items on Poshmark trying to figure out what would be a safe bet, going over the pieces again and again for flaws, and mostly just wondering if I was actually going to go through with it all or not.

Many people start a Poshmark closet to sell gently used items that they already own, but to be honest I didn’t have that much that I thought would get me a good return. Generally items that are originally sold for more money (think J. Crew, Anthropologie, Madewell, and of course, designer items) will do well on Posh, not stuff from Walmart, Old Navy, or Target. It makes sense since you can already get those brands for a really good deal without them being used.

Anyway, with my full cart I was scared to take the plunge! I mean, if I checked out with over $100 worth of stuff I was really going for it, right? I was worried it wasn’t going to work out, or I wasn’t going be able to sell anything. But I thought a lot about how if you don’t take any risks then you never learn. Even if I did fail it would be an experience that I could learn and grow from. So I went for it!

Another thing that kept going through my mind was all the amazing items I had found thrifting in the weeks before and had just left for someone else to find. That beautiful Theory cardigan I didn’t get because I don’t like polka dots but retails for over $300. Or the silk Madewell blouse that I didn’t get because it wasn’t my size (both pictured below). Or that Moulinette Soeurs green floral maxi dress, or those Everlane jeans. I could go on and on!

Starting a Poshmark Closet Reseller Thrift Finds-1
Starting a Poshmark Closet Reseller Thrift Finds-2

Honestly, you’re not going to find one of those super special pieces every time you thrift — I’m trying to accept that and think of all the other amazing things I will find in the future. And I bet that those items left behind probably made someone else very, very happy!

Listing Items on Poshmark

It makes sense that when you’re buying clothes online, especially with a no return policy like Poshmark has, that you want to see as much of the piece as possible. Having a great place to stage photos makes such a difference in being able to sell an item. I mean, would you buy a top if it was wrinkled, laid out on the carpet with a bunch of other stuff, and the photo was grainy? Probably not.

So I got excited to set up my ‘staging area’ for photographing my Poshmark listings. I wanted a white background so I put a command hook up in our bedroom and then placed a vase with fake leaves in it for a little more visual interest. Now in almost all of my photos you can see the fronds peeking out just a bit. And for when I’m photographing full length items, like maxi dresses, I place a sheepskin rug at the base of the garment.

Overall I’m really happy with how it turned out! After taking photos I edit them in Lightroom to get the colors and detail just right, and save them on my computer. Then I get ready to actually list the items on Poshmark, which isn’t as easy as it sounds. First I have to search around to see what other similar items are being sold for, if I can even find a similar item! Sometimes even with a popular brand like Free People I can’t find the exact item already being sold. I take into account the condition of the listed item and how long it’s been on the market for, while also what similar items have actually sold for (not what they’re listed as). So there’s a bit of research that goes into listing an item.

I track everything about my inventory (what it is, when I bought it, how much I got it for, when I listed it, how much I’m listing it for, etc.) so that I can see my earnings. Although I love to be organized this is more the ‘work’ side of Poshmark. I don’t necessarily love updating my spreadsheet unless it’s to see how much profit I’m making!

I downloaded the Poshmark inventory tracking spreadsheet from Ediza of Healthy Girl Fashion. If you’re interested in selling on Poshmark check it out!

Engaging with Others on Poshmark

What makes Poshmark so different from eBay or Craig’s List is how social the platform is. You need to follow other Poshers and share their listings, and other Poshers will do the same for you. Having your listings shared by more people means a larger audience that might ‘like’ the item. All likers on an item are given updates on price drops and can be sent private offers on the item. Likes are a great thing!

While it’s fun to engage with others, sometimes this aspect of selling on Poshmark is kind of annoying. You can’t just list an item and be done — you need to share your closet at least once a day and be on top of comments and questions posted to your item. On days when you don’t feel like responding to all the notifications Posh sends to your phone, it’s definitely one of the down aspects of being a reseller.

If you want to sign up as a buyer or seller on Poshmark, you can use the code COUNTDOWNTOFRI to get a $5 credit towards a purchase. I’ll also get a $5 credit once you make a purchase.


In a nutshell, getting started as a seller on Poshmark has been quite a whirlwind of emotions! I’m excited to see where it goes, but also nervous about the investment of my time and money. It can be a lot more work than people realize, but the joy at finding out something has sold and will make someone else on a budget very happy is a great feeling.

I plan on posting more about thrifting in general and Poshmark in the future, so let me know if you have any questions!

Have you used Poshmark before?

 

Related

   

Leave a Comment / Filed In: Fashion
Tagged: poshmark, Reselling, thrifted

Meet Kristin

Have thrifted clothes, will travel. And let’s get french fries.

I may receive commissions from clicks or purchases made through links on this blog. Thanks for supporting CTF.

Poshmark Closet

Closet Items

Shop more of my closet on Poshmark

For $10 off your first Poshmark purchase, use code COUNTDOWNTOFRI

#ONTHEGRAM

I took this photo 10 months ago to share some of m I took this photo 10 months ago to share some of my favorite thrift finds in a blog post, and I'm currently wearing this vintage sequin sweater today ❇️ I bought it for 99¢ during @arcthrift 's annual sweater sale, and it needed some help. I used dish soap to get a few white spots out of the fabric, and mended a small tear at the seam 🪡 I don't normally give that much care to my thrift finds, but this silk/angora/rabbit hair blend was so soft and the sequins are in perfect shape, so I gave it a shot! Very glad that I did ☺️ #secondhandstyle #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#whatimwearingtoday #secondhandfind #secondhandfirstchoice #secondhandfirst #thriftshopping #thriftunder100k #thriftedthis #thriftedoutfit #thriftstorestyle
I've never made a meme before but couldn't resist I've never made a meme before but couldn't resist 😂 Did you guys hear the story behind Bernie's mittens? They're made from old sweaters and lined with fleece from recycled water bottles! ♻️ Swipe to read more about who made them and why 🧤 #sustainablefashion #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#resellerlife #resellermemes #thriftmemes #berniememes #goodwilloutlet #goodwillbins #thrifterforlife #berniesandersmemes #secondhandstyle #secondhandfirst
Feeling like a million bucks in this perfect condi Feeling like a million bucks in this perfect condition vintage suede and wool coat I got at the Goodwill bins 😝 It's THE winter vacation coat if you ask me ❄️ Since you pay by the pound at the bins, this stunner cost about $5 😱 As a matter of fact, most of my outfit is secondhand: Brooks Brothers turtleneck, J. Crew jeans, and Coach purse via the thrift, and Kenneth Cole suede boots from Mercari 🏷️ Now heading home from a wonderful ski weekend in Beaver Creek 🎿 #secondhandstyle #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#secondhandfind #goodwillbins #goodwilloutletfinds #goodwilloutlet #secondhandfirst #thriftedoutfit #thriftstorestyle #gotitatgoodwill #affordableoutfit
9 years ago we were on our honeymoon in Iceland 🇮🇸 I just had to download this image off of Facebook (hence the low quality!) to post because this coat is thrifted 😂 I still have this coat and need to wear it more! It's a simple, long houndstooth coat. I found it at a big flea market in Florence when I was studying abroad for 25 euro. Once a thrifter, always a thrifter 😝 #secondhandstyle #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#fleamarketfinds #fleamarketstyle #thriftunder100k #thrifted #theviewfromhere #icelandtravel #icelandadventure #reykjavikiceland #honeymoontrip #secondhandfirst
Serving up this silk blend cardigan sweater with f Serving up this silk blend cardigan sweater with fringe detail that I got for $2.50 at the thrift 🤑 Definitely needs a good lint roll but when you're WFH who cares 🤷🏻‍♀️ if you could see my whole outfit there would be straight leg high rise jeans and super cozy wool socks 🧦 #wfhootd #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#secondhandstyle #secondhandfind #secondhandfirst #thriftunder100k #thriftedthis #thriftedstyle #secondhandfirstchoice #thriftstorestyle

Reader Faves

  • The Ups and Downs of Starting a Poshmark Closet
  • One Year of Selling on Poshmark in Review
  • The Ultimate Guide to Coffee Shops in Colorado Springs, CO
  • Coffee in Hand with Colorful Wings Mural The Ultimate Guide to the Best Coffee Shops in Richmond, Virginia
  • 4 Simple Steps to Concealing Dark Circles

What’s Pinning

Get the Countdown Delivered

#ONTHEGRAM

I took this photo 10 months ago to share some of m I took this photo 10 months ago to share some of my favorite thrift finds in a blog post, and I'm currently wearing this vintage sequin sweater today ❇️ I bought it for 99¢ during @arcthrift 's annual sweater sale, and it needed some help. I used dish soap to get a few white spots out of the fabric, and mended a small tear at the seam 🪡 I don't normally give that much care to my thrift finds, but this silk/angora/rabbit hair blend was so soft and the sequins are in perfect shape, so I gave it a shot! Very glad that I did ☺️ #secondhandstyle #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#whatimwearingtoday #secondhandfind #secondhandfirstchoice #secondhandfirst #thriftshopping #thriftunder100k #thriftedthis #thriftedoutfit #thriftstorestyle
I've never made a meme before but couldn't resist I've never made a meme before but couldn't resist 😂 Did you guys hear the story behind Bernie's mittens? They're made from old sweaters and lined with fleece from recycled water bottles! ♻️ Swipe to read more about who made them and why 🧤 #sustainablefashion #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#resellerlife #resellermemes #thriftmemes #berniememes #goodwilloutlet #goodwillbins #thrifterforlife #berniesandersmemes #secondhandstyle #secondhandfirst
Feeling like a million bucks in this perfect condi Feeling like a million bucks in this perfect condition vintage suede and wool coat I got at the Goodwill bins 😝 It's THE winter vacation coat if you ask me ❄️ Since you pay by the pound at the bins, this stunner cost about $5 😱 As a matter of fact, most of my outfit is secondhand: Brooks Brothers turtleneck, J. Crew jeans, and Coach purse via the thrift, and Kenneth Cole suede boots from Mercari 🏷️ Now heading home from a wonderful ski weekend in Beaver Creek 🎿 #secondhandstyle #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#secondhandfind #goodwillbins #goodwilloutletfinds #goodwilloutlet #secondhandfirst #thriftedoutfit #thriftstorestyle #gotitatgoodwill #affordableoutfit
9 years ago we were on our honeymoon in Iceland 🇮🇸 I just had to download this image off of Facebook (hence the low quality!) to post because this coat is thrifted 😂 I still have this coat and need to wear it more! It's a simple, long houndstooth coat. I found it at a big flea market in Florence when I was studying abroad for 25 euro. Once a thrifter, always a thrifter 😝 #secondhandstyle #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#fleamarketfinds #fleamarketstyle #thriftunder100k #thrifted #theviewfromhere #icelandtravel #icelandadventure #reykjavikiceland #honeymoontrip #secondhandfirst
Serving up this silk blend cardigan sweater with f Serving up this silk blend cardigan sweater with fringe detail that I got for $2.50 at the thrift 🤑 Definitely needs a good lint roll but when you're WFH who cares 🤷🏻‍♀️ if you could see my whole outfit there would be straight leg high rise jeans and super cozy wool socks 🧦 #wfhootd #countdowntofriday
.
.
.
#secondhandstyle #secondhandfind #secondhandfirst #thriftunder100k #thriftedthis #thriftedstyle #secondhandfirstchoice #thriftstorestyle

Theme by 17th Avenue · Powered by WordPress & Genesis

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Reject Read More
Privacy & Disclosure

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.